Skip to content
BuckeyePlaybook.com

BuckeyePlaybook.com

The Ohio Recipe Playbook

  • About
  • Tailgate
  • Sweets
  • Supper Club
BuckeyePlaybook.com
BuckeyePlaybook.com
The Ohio Recipe Playbook
  • Isaly’s Chipped Chopped Ham BBQ
    Tailgate & Savory

    Isaly’s Chipped Chopped Ham BBQ

    It’s not pulled pork. It’s not a sloppy joe. We break down the Ohio Valley classic: razor-thin chipped ham simmered in a tangy-sweet BBQ sauce, piled high on a soft bun.

    View Recipes Isaly’s Chipped Chopped Ham BBQContinue

  • Ohio Shredded Chicken Sandwich (“Hot Chicken”)
    Tailgate & Savory

    Ohio Shredded Chicken Sandwich (“Hot Chicken”)

    It’s not pulled pork. It’s not chicken salad. We break down the nostalgic Ohio concession stand classic—creamy, slow-cooked chicken thickened with Ritz crackers and served hot on a soft bun.

    View Recipes Ohio Shredded Chicken Sandwich (“Hot Chicken”)Continue

  • Cincinnati Opera Creams
    Sweets & Bakery

    Cincinnati Opera Creams

    Long before the candy bar, Cincinnati had the Opera Cream. Born in the historic candy shops of Over-the-Rhine and served during intermissions at Music Hall, these rich fondant centers dipped in dark chocolate are the definition of old-school elegance. Here is how to make the Queen City’s signature sweet at home.

    View Recipes Cincinnati Opera CreamsContinue

  • Lake Erie Yellow Perch (The North Coast Fry)
    The Ohio Supper Club

    Lake Erie Yellow Perch (The North Coast Fry)

    The Friday Night Fish Fry is a religion in Northern Ohio. We share the authentic North Coast method: sweet Lake Erie Yellow Perch, lightly breaded in cracker meal and fried to golden perfection.

    View Recipes Lake Erie Yellow Perch (The North Coast Fry)Continue

  • Barberton Fried Chicken (The Serbian Fry)
    The Ohio Supper Club

    Barberton Fried Chicken (The Serbian Fry)

    The ‘Chicken Capital of the World’ is right here in Ohio. We break down the authentic Serbian method: lard-fried, no batter, and served with the legendary ‘Hot Sauce’ rice.

    View Recipes Barberton Fried Chicken (The Serbian Fry)Continue

  • Akron Sauerkraut Balls (Ohio’s Original Tailgate Appetizer)
    Tailgate & Savory

    Akron Sauerkraut Balls (Ohio’s Original Tailgate Appetizer)

    Before wings ruled the parking lot, Ohio had Sauerkraut Balls. We break down the Hall-of-Fame recipe: savory pork sausage, tangy kraut, and cream cheese, deep-fried into the ultimate game day snack.

    View Recipes Akron Sauerkraut Balls (Ohio’s Original Tailgate Appetizer)Continue

  • Shaker Lemon Pie
    Sweets & Bakery

    Shaker Lemon Pie

    The 19th-century Shakers didn’t believe in waste, and they didn’t believe in shortcuts. This authentic Ohio pie uses the whole lemon—rind, pith, and all—cured in sugar for 24 hours to create a bold, bittersweet masterpiece. It’s a recipe that requires zero skill, but demands absolute patience.

    View Recipes Shaker Lemon PieContinue

  • The Waldo Fried Bologna Sandwich
    Tailgate & Savory

    The Waldo Fried Bologna Sandwich

    Forget the sad, curling pink disks from your school lunch tray. In the village of Waldo, bologna isn’t a deli meat—it’s a steak. We’re talking a half-inch slab of processed defiance, griddled until it’s charred, smoky, and angry. Stacked with onions, pickles, and melted jack cheese, it’s a sandwich that doesn’t apologize for what it is. It’s cheap, it’s heavy, and it’s the undisputed king of Central Ohio dive bars. Here is how to give bologna the respect it demands.

    View Recipes The Waldo Fried Bologna SandwichContinue

  • City Chicken (The “Chicken” Is A Lie)
    The Ohio Supper Club

    City Chicken (The “Chicken” Is A Lie)

    The greatest trick the Rust Belt ever pulled was convincing the hungry that this was poultry. Born in the shadows of Cleveland steel mills and Youngstown factories during the lean years, City Chicken is a delicious hustle. It’s pork disguised as a drumstick—breaded, fried, and skewered to hide the truth. It was a lie born of necessity, but it tasted so good we kept eating it long after the hard times rolled on. Here is how to cook the deception.

    View Recipes City Chicken (The “Chicken” Is A Lie)Continue

  • Classic Ohio Buckeyes (The Flagship Recipe)
    Sweets & Bakery

    Classic Ohio Buckeyes (The Flagship Recipe)

    The absolute non-negotiable flagship recipe. Smooth peanut butter centers, crisp chocolate, and the iconic ‘eye.’ If you only learn one Ohio dessert, this is it.

    View Recipes Classic Ohio Buckeyes (The Flagship Recipe)Continue

  • The Definitive Ohio Playbook to Cincinnati Chili
    Tailgate & Savory

    The Definitive Ohio Playbook to Cincinnati Chili

    The definitive guide to Ohio’s most polarizing dish. We break down the ‘No-Browning’ rule, the secret spice profile (it’s not just chocolate), and how to execute the perfect 5-Way for your next game day.

    View Recipes The Definitive Ohio Playbook to Cincinnati ChiliContinue

  • The Cleveland Polish Boy (Ohio’s Aggressive Sandwich)
    Tailgate & Savory

    The Cleveland Polish Boy (Ohio’s Aggressive Sandwich)

    Ohio’s most aggressive sandwich. Grilled kielbasa, crispy fries, coleslaw, and BBQ sauce jammed into one sturdy bun. We break down the definitive ‘North Coast’ method for the ultimate stadium food.

    View Recipes The Cleveland Polish Boy (Ohio’s Aggressive Sandwich)Continue

  • Cincinnati Goetta
    The Ohio Supper Club

    Cincinnati Goetta

    In the Queen City, breakfast isn’t a suggestion; it’s a contract. Meet Goetta. It’s not pretty, it’s not light, and it definitely isn’t Scrapple. It’s a brick of pork and steel-cut oats, seasoned hard and fried until it snaps back at you. This is the heavy hitter of Ohio mornings—a dish born from hard times that ended up tasting like victory. Here is how to make the crispest slice in the Midwest.

    View Recipes Cincinnati GoettaContinue

  • Schmidt’s-Style Jumbo Cream Puffs (German Village Legend)
    Sweets & Bakery

    Schmidt’s-Style Jumbo Cream Puffs (German Village Legend)

    Size matters in German Village. These aren’t delicate French pastries; they are softball-sized legends stuffed with a mountain of whipped cream. This is the Columbus icon that requires a fork, a nap, and zero apologies. Here is the playbook for baking the heavyweights of the Ohio dessert world.

    View Recipes Schmidt’s-Style Jumbo Cream Puffs (German Village Legend)Continue

  • Tony Packo’s Chili Dog (The Hungarian Dog)
    Tailgate & Savory

    Tony Packo’s Chili Dog (The Hungarian Dog)

    The chili dog that put Toledo on the map. We break down the MAS*H legend: Hungarian sausage, sturdy poppy seed buns, and a spicy, paprika-heavy chili sauce.

    View Recipes Tony Packo’s Chili Dog (The Hungarian Dog)Continue

  • Johnny Marzetti Casserole
    The Ohio Supper Club

    Johnny Marzetti Casserole

    The Columbus Classic Johnny Marzetti Casserole If Ohio had an “everybody-wins” comfort-food trophy, Johnny Marzetti would be hoisting it at midfield. Prep Time20 Mins Cook…

    View Recipes Johnny Marzetti CasseroleContinue

  • Ohio Valley “Square” Pizza
    Tailgate & Savory

    Ohio Valley “Square” Pizza

    East Ohio’s most controversial slice. We break down the ‘Steubenville Style’—thick square crust, tangy sauce, and the signature cold provolone finish that divides the state.

    View Recipes Ohio Valley “Square” PizzaContinue

  • Amish Fry Pies (Fried Fruit Hand Pies)
    Sweets & Bakery

    Amish Fry Pies (Fried Fruit Hand Pies)

    In Ohio’s Amish Country, the pie doesn’t wait for an oven. We share the authentic Holmes County recipe for Fry Pies—golden, hand-held fruit pies that are glazed while hot.

    View Recipes Amish Fry Pies (Fried Fruit Hand Pies)Continue

© Buckeye Playbook. All rights reserved.
About Privacy Policy Terms of Service Contact

Buckeye Playbook is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. This site also participates in other affiliate programs and displays advertisements via Google AdSense.

  • About
  • Tailgate
  • Sweets
  • Supper Club